tank.gif
Live Updates From the Durban World Cup Print E-mail
User Rating: / 14
PoorBest 
Written by Alain Jaques   
Saturday, 30 June 2007
red7blacklogoOfficial Results and a transcript of the coverage of the ARB Surfski World Cup. We were in cellphone contact with the race referee John Parton and his crew who relayed events to us as they unfolded from the race support boats. 
 
There was massive drama in the form of a container ship that crossed the path of the leading bunch and plunged the race into controversy. 

This commentary is sponsored by Red7 Surfskis, visit Red7 by clicking on the banner above.

Official Results

Oscar Chalupsky was confirmed as the winner followed by Hank McGregor and Dean Gardiner. This after Hank lodged a protest against Oscar's win claiming that he was prejudiced when they were required to stop as the ship was about to cross their path. Oscar and Hank arrived at the ship together and were stopped by race officials, they were then waved through ahead of the ship. The protest was investigated but in the end Oscar's win was upheld. Apparently Hank was not at the prize giving. It will be interesting to get Hank and Oscars version of the events and view the video footage.

Arrival times at the ship were noted and finishing times were adjusted for these times, therefore the arrival time at the beach may differ in some cases. There were no other protests but I'm sure there are some happy and some much less happy finishers.

 Mens Race

  1. Oscar Chalupsky - SA
  2. Hank McGregor - SA
  3. Dean Gardiner - AU
  4. Matt Bouwman - SA
  5. Tim Jacobs - AU
  6. Dawid Mocke - SA
  7. Herman Chalupsky - SA
  8. Barry Lewin - SA
  9. Ash Nesbitt - AU
  10. Daryl Bartho - SA
Jasper was 12th (just thought I'd mention it before you grill me about my wild race prediction).

Women

  1. Alexa Lombard - SA
  2. Michelle Eder -
  3. Tiffany Kruger - SA

Doubles

  1. Simon and Andrew Blackburn - SA

Veterans

  1. Oscar Chalupsky

Masters

  1. Rod Taylor
Team Prize goes to South Africa.

 

12:00 - It's been fun and thanks for all the comments. Keep them coming an keep them clean. If anyone has further news please post them on the comments.

11:30 - Rob M has just called in, the talk on the beach is that Dean Gardiner was in third place behind Hank who was behind Oscar, after that things are scratchy.

He says the seas were BIG, the biggest swells he has ever paddled, he took a swim after "going over the falls backwards". On a Millers Run Scale he gives it 11/10 - "there were huge sea swells coming inshore and smaller wind swells going out, you could catch the wind swell and turn onto the giant fast moving sea swells, I was screaming along at 23km/h at one stage - it was awesome fun".

11:20 - Well it is an anticlimax to a great race, there will be a meeting in an hour's time to listen to the protests.

10:56 - It must have been mayhem out there. Skis racing in a big downwind within sight of the finish, all gunning it, and along comes a massive container ship right across their path, two ski's slip through ahead of the ship and the chase boats hold the rest of fleet. It must have been like herding cats and some slipped through. I can just imagine the chaos - I can't wait for the TV footage.

John can't give official results, even Oscar and Hank's positions are not confirmed.

10:45 - No official result, protests are flying as some contestants allegedly pushed past the container ship under a red flag. Paddlers on the beach are Oscar, Hank, then in no specific order the Aussies Tim Jacobs, Murray Stewart, Kissane, SA's Steve Woods, Japs and Daw Mocke, Barthos bros, Barry Lewin, Paul Marais.

The image below shows where the drama occurred. You can see where the harbor mouth and the race course cross. It was the worst timing possible for a ship to be leaving the harbor.

race_finish

 

10:36 - OSCAR is first home by 150m followed by Hank, the sprint pack are coming in, they are going to finish seconds apart. Apparently there were skis all around the massive container ship, bad timing Mr Harbourmaster.

10:35 - Oscar is sprinting in 100 meters in front of Hank he read it perfectly coming in from the deep and skirting around the point. Behind is a chase pack of 10 boats. 

10:30 - Massive drama, a container ship is coming out the harbour mouth, two skis have skirted in front of it Oscar and Hank the rest are being held by the chase boats.

10:26 - Back from the deep are Dawid Mocke and Oscar Chalupsky, they are up with Hank after taking a 'deep deep line'...

The paddlers are approaching the harbour mouth..

Other in contention are Woods, Jacobs, Lewin and Bartho. 

10:15 - Dawid Mocke is nowhere to be seen! Did he take a swim or is he on a different line. The chase boats report difficulty keeping tabs on the leaders as they spread out in the swells. With all the whitecaps every wave looks like it has a surfski on it.

Hank is being caught by Woods, Jacobs, Jasper Mocke, Barry Lewin and Darryl Bartho. It is impossible to tell who is in the lead. 

The inshore line is the faster, paddlers are flying and are expected in within the next 15 to 20 mins. They will have to round the bluff and turn toward the beach with the wind and swells from their side. 

10:05 am - Postitions unchanged, HMG, SW, TJ, DM.
The leaders are approaching the "bluff" which is the finger of land that separates the harbour from the sea - check it out on google earth by searching for Durban.

Apparently on half a dozen boats never made it out through the surf but double that are scattered along the shore. Nothing serious but hard work for the support boats. There is also a helicopter keeping an eye on things. 

10:00am - Hank McGregor is still in the lead. Big surprise though is second placed Steve Woods!!! where did he come from? Third is Tim Jacobs and then Dawid Mocke. Those are all the positions I have.

Steve Woods is a new name to me, apparently he is a paddler from East London a coastal town between Cape Town and Durban, better know as 'slummies'. His dad is a big legend in surf lifesaving.

John says they are very busy on the water with safety issues. I guess the big conditions are tough on those more accustomed to flat water.

9:40am - Big drama at the start in the surf, the race is 40% underway, they are flying and are already at Isipingo near the airport, top four are

  1. Hank McGregor
  2. Dawid Mocke
  3. Tim Jacobs
  4. "One of the Chalupsky's"

The doubles started 20 minutes after the singles and there was drama at the start with broken boats and lost paddles. A few paddlers have retired with broken of lost equipment. One paddler got a "surfki in the back" and is "sore", he is being treated by medics (we don't know who it is).

Most boats got out fine. 

John is on his way to Durban by car, he is in cell phone contact with the chase boats but with the wind they are not hearing their phones ringing. 

You can see Isipingo on the image below where the first arrow head points. 

Course

 

9:25 am - John's phone is ringing, the race is scheduled to be starting now which is probably why he is not answering....

9:00 am - Waiting for the start...  this is going to be a great test of who is the best surfski paddler in proper downwind conditions. I think most paddlers will follow Oscar's line, he knows this route better than anyone and must have paddled it hundreds of times. The beach start adds compexity to the race, if you take a swim you will struggle to make up the time lost. Those that get around the cans first and into the downwind leg with the swells and wind behind them will increase their lead substantially over those still paddling across the wind and swells.

Here's my top 10 wild prediction for the race based on nothing but gut feel, bias and optimism. Jasper and Dawid introduced me to this sport at surfskischool, Oscar and Dean are surfski legends - good enough reason in my book for the top 4 places.

1. Jasper Mocke
2. Dawid Mocke
3. Dean Gardiner
4. Oscar Chalupsky
5. Barry Lewin
6. Tim Jacobs
7. Hank McGregor
8. Matt Bouwmann
9. Clint Pretorius
10. Dave Kissane

As for our roving reporter and good friend Rob Mousley, well he broke his ski last year and damaged his shoulder the year before so his big match temperament is doubtful. I'm sure the surf is freaking him out too, once he is on the runs he will do great. Sorry Rob you don't make the top 10 buddy but all the best.

8:30 am - Bill Harker is busy with the race briefing, the wind is pumping, I can hear it through John's phone, he says it is more like 35kts at the moment. The paddlers are lined up on the southern side of the beach which gives them a clear run to cans (buoys) out at sea, paddlers must round the cans on the seaward side before turning north for Durban. Darryl Bartho says this is going to be a fast race and predicts a winning time of 1h40 for the 29km to Durban.

There are seven rubber ducks following the race with officials, safety crews and TV crews. I for one am looking forward to some excellent video footage of top class paddlers in classic downwind conditions.

8:00 am -  Race Referee John Parton says conditions are 'absolutely perfect' for a downwind race, there are smiles all around on the faces of the SA paddlers and the International paddlers are equally excited. Out at sea there are big swells running tipped with whitecaps. The surf break at the beach is "flat as a pancake, you won't even wet your hair going out" according to Alan. Roving Rob however nervously reports a "bit of a break"...

The start will be between 8:30 and 9:15 and will be from the beach, it is much easier to line the paddlers up on the beach than out at sea in a 30knot wind. Lifejackets are recommended but not compulsory.


toti

  Amanzimtotoi beach from the website www.amanzimtoti.kzn.org.za

  7:30am - Conditions in Durban are perfect for a classic downwind, I had a chat to Rob earlier and he says the wind is 'howling'. This is fantastic news for most paddlers and the organizers. Downwind paddling is more a test of how much energy you can get out of the sea than how much you put in. These conditions must favour the old men of the sea like Oscar and Dean who have spent more time in a surfski than anyone else.

Windguru shows the wind will be blowing between 35 and 42 km/h from the SW with a swell of 2m running in the same direction. According to Rob there are a few clouds around.

windguru

7:00am Text messages have gone out to all the competitors from legendary race organiser Billy Harker, the message reads "ARB Surfski World Cup. Race Check in close 8:15. Must get a wrist band @ check in. Bring L/Jckts + Leash. Wind IS Blowing! Start @ Toti Main Beach" - this commentator is glad safety gear is being checked, safety has clearly been given high priority after a paddler got into trouble in the surf during a series race a few weeks ago and was rescued by fellow paddlers. See the article Surf Smashes Paddlers for more on the incident.


The course, Amanzimtoti to Durban

 

Hits: 7071
Comments (79)Add Comment
Good Luck to all competitors
written by Downwind Specialist??????, July 01, 2007
6.15am
The wind is currently blowing at 19-21 Knots SW and will get up to 25- 35 Knots SSW in an hours time, according to Durban Weather Office. Bring it on, finally a proper downwind. May the best Ski paddler win!!

Oscar Chalupsky
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Oscar to Take it.
written by Peter Willis, July 01, 2007
No doubt now boys. He will not be beaten in these conditions. 44yrs old and a real threat to the young guys. I accept that Dean is a threat as well. Cannot wait. If you win this one - no issues - you are the top paddler in the World today.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Hi from Hong Kong
written by Robbie stewart, July 01, 2007
This is Robbie Stewart (Murray's father - sitting in Hong Kong rubbing my computer screen to get your news.

Two things:
1.) Murray has warmed up and is still feeling weak - he says he will start off slowly and see how he feels. It is a pity becuase despite what some of the Soiuth African boys have been saying the Aussoes spend a lot of time in big swells of North Head in Sydney - they are a lot trickier than anythingg you get in KZN because of the swell being deflected off the cliffs. Murray's ski coach is not called Tony "the Animal" Vieceli for nothing!
2.) The race referee is John Parton - At least John told be yesterdatyy that he was the crace referee.

I like your website!

Robbie Stewart
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Race
written by GD, July 01, 2007
Tossed work for the day. Just cannot go in and pretend I am working when all I am thinking about is the race, WISH I WAS THERE. Great conditions. Can Rob M win this thing??

GD
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
GD
written by Christo Tromp, July 01, 2007
GD, u just know how to provoke us construction workers. will have to sort this out with a tussle on the water
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
drama at start
written by Christo Tromp, July 01, 2007
Alain

Please could you briefly elaborate on the drama at the start. Who was swimming?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Drama at start
written by Alain Jaques, July 01, 2007
John did not elaborate or mention any of the big names or Rob's name for that matter. I got the impression that there was more drama with the doubles than with the singles. Maybe the doubles set off just as a big wave set was coming in.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
RUBBING THE SCREEN!
written by Robbie stewart, July 01, 2007
Hi Alain,

You have me in Hong Kong the rest on my family in Manly and thewhole world including paddlers in Dubai hanging on for news. Tell John "Ostrich" to give us some news!

Robbie
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
comments
written by pez, July 01, 2007
Great job Alain! Don't want to ask the impossible but it would be nice to know how if the front pack is tight or spread etc...thanks mate, understand you are doing your best.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Shamaal
written by GD, July 01, 2007
We are trying to do GPS live positioning - as this is to much to cope with. We need the race live! baby.

Go you good thing Steve Woods - good East London surf boy!!

GD
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
WHAT
written by GD, July 01, 2007
Are you telling me that the race is spoilt as the ship came out?????????
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
1 April ???
written by Ed Menzies, July 01, 2007
Hope it's just your sense of humour!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
WELL DONE BIG LAD!!!
written by GD, July 01, 2007
44yrs old - and World Champ.

I told you guys - he will not be passed in Downwind.

Can we put the Deano v Oscar thread to bed now??
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Container Ship
written by Christo Tromp, July 01, 2007
What a load of 'bollocks', Can someone please ?papa kilo? that guy. Thank you Mr. Harbor Master, or is it called harbor disaster smilies/angry.gif
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
what a joke
written by Barnesy, July 01, 2007
A great event. Well organised, promoted and attended. Only to be completely ruined by that container ship. What a pathetic way to finish. I feel sorry for those guys that got held back.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
the big 'O'
written by Christo Tromp, July 01, 2007
Congrats Oscar,
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Oh Sh*t.
written by GD, July 01, 2007
I take back my congratulations until it is sorted out. Did anybody think to call the Harbour master and say - at about x time - 10 of the Worlds best ski paddlers are going to be going across the mouth at high speed. As far as I know ships have scheduled leaving times - like flights out of an airport. All they needed was a 15 min window. After that a ski would have been out of contention - and then OK to wait.
When they got permission to cross the mouth - this must have come up?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Re-Run
written by shocker, July 01, 2007
Remember the window is until Monday - I propose the race be re-run tomorrow. Waiting to hear the facts though. I think the way the officials handle this is important for the future of the race.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Extremely happy.
written by flick, July 01, 2007
Ah yes....... the smell of victory. Well done Oscar and all the boys in Durbs. Pity about the ship but still a good race, lets be honest. I am very happy that Oscar won the WC in his own back yard. 44 and still winning WC`s in Aus and S.A. Outstanding. Undoubtably the world greatest ocean paddler of all time.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
You'd think so
written by Barnesy, July 01, 2007
I agree with you GD 100%. When races are organised on Sydney Harbour, this is what happens. In fact not just container ships.....the entire ferry fleet is put on hold for the "window" of reasonable time.

The containder ship should not have been there. If Oscar and Hank had been held up with everyone else.....it still ruins a great event.

Oscar may have still won without the container ship. But now we will never know and the result will always be disputed.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Re run
written by GD, July 01, 2007
If there is even 1% dispute. They have to re run.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by BenH, July 01, 2007
NO one can claim this as a victory. I don't think anyone would want to.

From what I gather with the distances involved, any number of the top guys could have had enough gas to sprint their guts out to victory.

A shallow, disputed victory is all the Big O will get from this one.

No-one will remember the winners name and effort, only the "what if?...." scenario.

Spare a thought for the organizers as they will be copping all types crap right now.

Harbour Master needs a visit!


report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Flicks a goose
written by fed, July 01, 2007
Mate, fancy mouthing off like that considering the circumstances. You're a goose.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
do as I say not as I do
written by non saffa, July 01, 2007
After accussing Lewis at cheating at molo, It sounds like a few saffas have done as they pleased. Great coverage!!!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by BenH, July 01, 2007
RE-RUN

There needs to be a definitive result for it to count.

I am dissapointed.

Does this mean I get my money back from our wager Danny?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Come on Boys
written by GD, July 01, 2007
Lets just wait for the result or re run. We are all a bit angry. Wait for an hour. Lets just think of the organiser who is about to get a heap of dung on his desk. Oscar will not take a victory he did not earn 100% fairly. Nor would any Oz champ. Lets see.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Penalty shootout?
written by Alain Jaques, July 01, 2007
I don't have the full details but if there is doubt then maybe a penalty shootout is called for. Those who got held up should race again tomorrow to sort it out. Otherwise there will always be controversy.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Where were they
written by Wally, July 01, 2007
You can say what you like, where were the chasers. If they were with Oscar and Hank, they would have made it as well, obvoiusly they were a long way behind at that stage. If I saw a container ship approaching me I would not be playing chicken with it.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
2 from 2
written by Karl Treacher, July 01, 2007
Last year they ran the race in flat conditions and this year they forgot to ring the shipping authorities. For those of you who have done one of Dean's races in Perth, you would know that this just doesn't happen if the race is properly organised.

Another amazing waste of Aussie dollars to go to an event that is clearly run by those who don't know how to run one. Looks like I am 5k better off for staying in Sydney and watching Australia smash the Kiwis.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Dear Wally
written by con, July 01, 2007
If OC and HMG were clear of the pack and weren't told to stop by the officials fair enough, but there are other scenarios, such as igoring instructions or maybe they were just further out to sea but not necessarily in front. We're all a bit anxious but one thing is for sure, us people on this website don't know what went down so lets just hold fire. No doubt there will be time for bragging soon.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
wallys a wally
written by non saffa, July 01, 2007
Propably following the directions of the RED FLAG!!!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Window period
written by Christo Tromp, July 01, 2007
I agree with GD that there should be an window period for these types of race that passes harbor and other racing events. But then also think about this scenario, you are not one of these elite paddlers, but you have paddled your hart out for the last, 70min, barely staying in front of the next contender. Now a container vessel stops you, causing this contender to catch-up with you. After the vessel has passed you, just don't seem to have the energy to catch this other guy, for you have lost your rhythm and your advantage.

I say there should either not be race in front of harbors, or have it done as the Aussies (Thank you Barnesy), and stop all boat traffic for the time of the race. Making it fair to all paddlers, to do the best they can
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Re-run
written by Ocean Warrior, July 01, 2007
Unless the officials rule that the chasing pack was several hundred metres off the pace....then it has to be re-run tomorrow. But it sounds like the conditions would have made it very difficult to judge where people were.

Just as well Lewis Laughlin wasn't there racing. Had he been one of the paddlers to get across in front of the container ship, he probably would have been accused of surfing its wake!!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Karl Preacher
written by Ed Menzies, July 01, 2007
Has a positive comment ever come out of your mouth? You need a dog mate coz u must be one of the unhappiest dudes around. I hope you are swallowing huge amounts of humble pie for your comments about Oscar!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Sorry boys
written by Wally, July 01, 2007
Generally the races are well run in SA.
I hear your comments, however at the harbour entrance all would have been together by that stage, if you were far out at the wall you would not be in the race, you would want to keep close to the wall after rounding it for protection against the wind. Hank took the inside line from what I can gather from the reports, Oscar was not even mentioned as being with the front paddlers, which means he was to far out for the spoters to see him.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by BenH, July 01, 2007
I think Con is right.

Here we all are swearing and typing like demons when in all honesty we don't have the facts.

I am sure as soon as anyone knows Alain and Rob will post it.

Ed, Karl is half right. Flat conditions are uncontrollable.

A large tanker doesn't just pop up out of the blue, neither can it juat stop to let paddlers through. Poor planning, poor communication or the Harbour Master's been given a back hander. Avoidable (the latter if you give th HM a bigger bribe).

I know some of the Aussie guy's and they have trained bloody hard for this event, spent alot of money, taken time off work and family commitments to be there. For what?

An awesome event in perfect conditions - ruined by an avoidable event.

RE-RUN or RE-FUND?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
relax ed, you will be ok mate
written by karl treacher, July 01, 2007
yeah ed. Just spoke to Dean who finished 3rd. Whisper has it that oscar and hank may be DQ...i look forward to meeting you ed. You sound just like my grade 6 girlfreind and I imagine you look the same although she probably had more integrity than to write protagonistic comments on a blog. loser.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by BenH, July 01, 2007
You must admit this is actually quite exciting?

It will also make for interesting reading for the next day or so.

I look forward to the war of words.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Karl and Ed
written by Alain Jaques, July 01, 2007
Chill Karl and Ed, your latest comments are pushing things, have your say but don't get personal, rather google each-other and flame war by email if you have to. Keep on topic and keep it civil or I will hit the delete button.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by Barnesy, July 01, 2007
Treach - you're cracking me up. Normally you're so chilled. I reckon those Saffa's must have done something to you on one of your Molokai trips.

BTW - if Deano came 3rd and was held up by the chase boats....then it is a bloody good effort for him to out sprint those younger guys to the finish.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
shame on you
written by Christo Tromp, July 01, 2007
Everyone is screaming for a re run, but know that there are rumors flying around that OC and Hank , may be disqualified, and Deano might be the winner, No one mentions anything. Let there be a re-run. The RSA boys will still come up champions.

Karl, if you would like to meet ed, just use some of the 5k u have saved for this trip and come down to Dubai, where, for your information, the conditions will be flat. As a paddler should only be called a good paddler, if he/she can paddle in any conditions
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Karl & Ed
written by GD, July 01, 2007
Guys Guys Guys - Ed you are so relaxed normally - and the boys say you are as well Karl. I demand that Karl & Ed get free beers at the Barasti Bar during the Shamaal - on the World Cup organisers. I mean causing massive stress to already tough Oz & SA relations - 4 cases at least. Then you two are going over the pool on a pole - with pillows. Last man standing.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by BenH, July 01, 2007
Actually Christo, they have been asking for a re-run. The last 7 posts have concerned Karl and Ed. Much more interesting.


report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
pillow fight
written by Christo Tromp, July 01, 2007
GD, good going , please arrange some of those 'epic' beers, for that will be an 'epic' battle.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
......
written by Ed Menzies, July 01, 2007
Karl we all agree the race was ruined...maybe a re-run...whatever, but hey bring your ozzies dolars to Dubai.(if you haven't got space for ski & ex-girlfriend - u know which one to dump).
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by Christo Tromp, July 01, 2007
Ben H

correct bro, what a great tussle. I still think that GD's pillow fight sounds cool
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
last reports
written by Michael A, July 01, 2007
Rumor has it the ocean tanker was wash riding lewis while on a copied ski, but its ok because the tanker was only 70% copied off an Australian style tanker made in China......
guys, guys, guys If Oscar is the champ he earns that title and congratulations to him. he may not be the best looking guy in the world but gee he can paddle. I dedicate the name "Oscar" to my birth of my first born son...mabe in a couple of years, as long as he doesnt have red hair.
I just hope whatever decision made by the race committee is in the best interest of the sport, not which Nation came first.
Sorry to all paddlers who were held up. Does anyone know if there were rules involved in case of this happening (I hope so seeing this is the fist WC sanctioed by the International canoe federation).
Congratulations to Oscar if that result is final.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
I'm outta here
written by Alain Jaques, July 01, 2007
I just spoke to Rob who says he will update the site as soon as he gets to a computer. Check back in a while for an update.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
regarding - last report
written by Christo Tromp, July 01, 2007
Thank for that Michael A, I hope the ICF looks into your allegations.

Yes guys, besides the point of win or loose. Congrats to the guys that have finished this great race, and I hope to be there next year for the same or even a better experience.

Congrats to the winners, and I hope to meet you all at the Shamaal in November.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
what about the girls??
written by Yanda Nossiter, July 01, 2007
Can anyone tell me who won the girls??
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Thoughts of re run??
written by Michael A, July 01, 2007
Yes the event has a 3 day window to be competed. but when deciding to do this people need to take in many considerations. Someone like the Big "O" and Dean are unlikely to back up to race again in the same physical condition because of their age (not saying they can't). A re run would favor the likes of Hank, Tim, Dawid (& Murray to overcome sickness) because the way they can back up the very next day. A re run is not a pausable option because of the various circumstance of the competitors. ie Age, travel arrangments, buisness committment and Individual physiological capabilities.
When planning to race a world Cup in any sport you train spefically for that event, not to race the same distance again the next day at the same level as which you competed the previous day.
The race is run and the decision is up to the race referee. Consultation should be seeked with the ICF as ultimately they are the governing body of the race although they may played no role in the organisation of this event and setting of the rules (I do not know personally).
lets also throw in another concern... if a re-run were to happen would there be drug testing??? As performance enhancers also help with the recovery....
Are the rules available to be viewed by any interested parties??
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by Mark Bata, July 01, 2007
There should be a re run. It was unfortunate that the last part of the race was marred by a leaving container ship. Based from the reports posted, it could have been anyone in the winners circle.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
RE-RUN
written by pez, July 01, 2007
The positives for a re-run outweigh the negatives - so what if the boys weren't expecting it. It's not like it was a 5 hour slog in hot conditions. It was all about skill and in cool conditions.

By the sounds of it (so far) no-one can claim to be the best on the day.

WE NEED A REAL WINNER - don't leave the fans hangin' out like this after all the build-up and banter.

RE-RUN the RACE
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Events Director
written by Nigel Reynolds, July 01, 2007
Congrats to all the paddlers and a great profile event for South Africa, I believe this one is the organizers fault in not communicating with the harbour master, Durban is South Africa's most active port and systems should have been in place - In 2001 King of the Harbour World challenge in Cape Town V& A waterfront had the Harbour master on the event committe and he put a Tug in the harbour entrance to control movement while leaders Herman, Henk & Lewis - This was also important as 1st prize was valued at $115,000 dollars

The paddlers have given it 200% and given the conditions and the fact that Hank & Oscar outwitted the Ship they deserve the podium and 3rd to 10th place should be given a few extra dollars in the name of the sport.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by Ben Hines, July 01, 2007
Nigel,

Saying that Hank & Oscar outwited the ship is a little niave.

Imagine if one of them had been run down by the ship? There is no 'outwitting' a contaciner ship that takes 2km to stop.

If they ignored race official's instructions and put themselves at risk then they should be DQ'd. (Assuming they ignored the red Flag).

If there was a fatality due to a gamble with a 1000tonne ship then you watch what happens to the ARB world cup next year? gone.

You try and get Public Liability or Event Insurance when something as simple to avoid as major vessle traffic scheduling is a screw up.

By playing with that boat they may have made future events very hard if not too expensive to run.

I reiterate, if they knowingly ignored red flags etc. (It is a theoritical hypothesis at the moment).
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Lost your Boat
written by Rusty Pelican, July 01, 2007
Hi, Found a ski washed up at Umdloti. Call to describe if its yours - 0836783322
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Who is at Fault?
written by JJ, July 01, 2007
Things brings up many interesting thoughts-

1) Is it the Harbor Master or race organizer's fault? Did they go over all of the possible scenerios ahead of time with Harbor Master's? Inform paddlers what to do if a large container ship is coming?

2)This situation makes me think of Molokai mess all over, but in different light. When 4 or 5 people/sponsors make all of the decisions in terms of a race, then they make the best course for the elite paddlers and then invite everyone to try to have the best turn out. The event is pulled in different directions.

3)We certainly don't know all of the facts, but one thing we do know-Oscar did what he wanted to, how he wanted to, and when he wanted to on the course. As always.

Aloha
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
OC
written by PC, July 01, 2007
Simply the greatest open ocean paddler the World has ever known. Sorry guys - just accept it. Bring me any other with 11 Molo's - who knows how many PE /EL's, at 44yrs of age, to be running with a fit young lad like Hank is enough, never mind beat him, as he did in Perth & Dubai.

Just say well done amd marvel at the fact he can do what he does.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by eric marinier, July 01, 2007
and what's about the frenchs paddlers????
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
French Paddlers
written by OP, July 01, 2007
They all struggled and didn't finish. It was way to big for them.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by eric marinier, July 01, 2007
even franck fifils ??
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Pics
written by Mulletman, July 01, 2007
enough what-ifs, anyone got some pics for those of us that couldn't make it?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Pics
written by Alain Jaques, July 01, 2007
Rob the roving reporter has a memory stick full of pictures, unfortunately real-life has intervened and he will be away on a business trip tomorrow. The pictures will be up as soon as Rob has a chance.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Franck
written by xpat, July 01, 2007
Franck fifil did really well, finished about 40th single. He was padling for the Caribbean team -Ludovic Gaffin (19 yars) alo di well, finishing in justover 2 hours.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Good job Rob
written by Karl Treacher, July 02, 2007
Nice work again Rob on your coverage mate. Sounds like we will be hearing many differing views for some time yet.

It is good to see that all world cup events now are sticking to the agreed criteria of downwind conditions. I only make comment regarding poor organisation due to the sacrifices many paddlers make to compete. It is always disappointing when you have sacrificed time with family, money and career opportunities to train for an event and it is badly run or isn't in line with international standards. Sounds like this event was well run, just may have missed the ship thing.

Its a pity some people get all worked up about these suggestions when I only make them to increase pressure to ensure we all get a fair go. I would also suggest Rob that you get people to sign in as their own name verified by email to help people stay away from abusive and unecessary comments...many of which are untrue. People are more likely to pull their head in if they know that they can be identified at a race...

Again, good job.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Get over it
written by CC, July 02, 2007
Oscar won get over it and stop making excuses
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Easy to mouth off under an alias
written by Ben Hines, July 02, 2007
I agree with Karl 100%.

Rob, I think it a great idea that people can only comment using their real names and not under the safety of anomimity.

People are much more likely to make sensible and thought out comment as opposed to mouthing off and insulting others to make a point.

Besides if what they have to say is valid then why not use their real names?

May be out of habit developed from them using more dubious web sites (if you know what I mean?). smilies/wink.gif smilies/wink.gif